X
Español | Português
Call us today: UT: 801-884-3775   TX: 469-552-5992

Custodial interference is what Utah calls it when a parent keeps a child from the other parent during that parent’s court-ordered time. It is both a violation of the custody order, which the family court can punish, and a crime under Utah Code 76-5-303, which the police and prosecutors can charge. Parents on both sides of it tend to misunderstand it: the withholding parent often believes they had a good reason, and the parent being kept from the child often believes the police will simply go get the child. Neither is quite right. Here is how it works.

What the statute covers

Under Utah Code 76-5-303, a person commits custodial interference when, without good cause, they take, entice, conceal, detain, or withhold a child from the person entitled to custody or parent-time, with the intent to interfere with that custody or parent-time.

The statute cuts both ways. A custodial parent who keeps the child during the other parent’s visitation commits the offense. So does a noncustodial parent who keeps the child past the end of their visitation and refuses to return the child to the custodial parent. The key is a court order that gives the other person the right to the child at that time, and an intent to interfere with it.

Because an order is required, custodial interference generally does not apply where there is no custody order at all. Married parents with no case filed, or unmarried parents with no custody order, each have equal rights to the child, and neither commits the crime by taking the child. Our article on whether your ex can take the kids without telling you explains that situation.

The penalties

A first custodial interference offense is a class B misdemeanor. It becomes a class A misdemeanor if the person has been convicted of custodial interference at least twice in the two years before the current offense. It becomes a third degree felony if, during the interference, the person removes the child from Utah, or causes or directs the child to be removed from the state.

Along with the criminal penalty, the family court has its own remedies: make-up parent-time, attorney fees, a finding of contempt, and, in repeated or serious cases, a change of custody. In our experience the family court consequences are the ones that matter most to parents, because they are the ones that change who has the children going forward.

The defenses

The statute recognizes two affirmative defenses.

The first is consent. If the parent entitled to the time agreed to the change, there is no interference. This is why agreed schedule changes should always be confirmed in writing; a text saying “fine, keep her through Sunday” is a complete defense, and a verbal agreement that one parent later denies is not.

The second is protection of the child. A parent who reasonably believes the withholding is necessary to protect the child from abuse has a defense, but only if the parent reports the belief and the basis for it to child protective services or law enforcement before the withholding. This requirement is what most withholding parents miss. Keeping the child because you are worried and calling DCFS afterward does not qualify. Report first, then act, and be prepared to prove the basis.

“The child did not want to go” is not a defense, and neither is “the other parent is behind on child support.” A child’s refusal is the parent’s problem to manage, and support and parent-time are legally separate obligations. Withholding a child over money is interference; withholding money over a child is a support violation. Neither is permitted.

What to do if your ex is withholding your child

Document the missed exchange. Note the date, time, and place, what you did, and what the other parent said. Keep every text and email. If you have a co-parenting app, use it.

Ask for the child in writing. A short, calm message stating that it is your parent-time under the order and asking when the child will be returned creates a record of intent.

Involve the police if appropriate. Officers can take a report and, in some jurisdictions, will accompany you to an exchange, but most will not physically remove a child from a parent over a civil custody dispute unless the child has been taken out of state or is in danger. Bring a certified copy of your order. A police report is valuable evidence even if nothing happens that day.

File a motion to enforce. This is the step that actually gets results. The family court can order make-up time, fees, and sanctions, and repeated findings support a modification of custody. Utah’s Rule 100A case tracks have made enforcement motions move faster than they used to.

Do not retaliate. Do not withhold the child in return, do not stop paying support, and do not show up at the other parent’s home uninvited. Judges see both parents’ conduct, and the parent who stayed within the order is the one who wins.

What to do if you are the one being accused

If you kept your child because you believed they were in danger, get the report to DCFS or police made now if you have not, and get an emergency motion filed in the family case. If you kept the child for any other reason, return the child, put your reasons in writing to your attorney, and let the court process handle the underlying problem. A parent facing a custodial interference charge should have both a family law attorney and, if charges have been filed, criminal defense counsel.

The bigger picture

Utah’s custody statutes reward parents who support the child’s relationship with the other parent and penalize parents who interfere with it. Custodial interference findings, criminal or civil, become part of the record in every future custody decision. If your parent-time is being interfered with, act early, act through the court, and keep your own conduct clean. If you are tempted to withhold, call an attorney first.

CoilLaw handles custody enforcement and defense throughout Utah. We can review your order, tell you whether what happened qualifies as interference, and file the motion that fixes it.

This article is general information about Utah law, not legal advice for your situation.

Related reading

Found this helpful? Add CoilLaw as a preferred source to see more of our guides in Google Search.

X

How to Survive and Thrive When Your Marriage Ends

Learn More